Polymath Research Logo Polymath Research
← Back to blog

A Civilization That Does Not Value Soil

・ 6 min read ・ Author: Yachiko Obara / Hiroki Obara

Lately, we hear more and more about plant factories. Apparently there is even a grand name for it: Controlled Environment Agriculture (CEA). It is a farming method that monitors and controls the growing environment inside a facility, such as light, temperature, humidity, CO₂ concentration, water and nutrients, to stabilize crop yield and quality. It is said to be the solution that will save humanity’s future.

Stories like this have existed since ancient times. It is the idea that “humans are all-powerful, and nature is something to be conquered.” This idea lies at the very foundation of the development of natural science in Western civilization.

A Civilization That Does Not Value Soil Has a Short Life

Unfortunately, however, a civilization that does not value soil has a short life. Ancient Mesopotamia, the Roman Empire, the Maya: most of the civilizations that flourished in history declined and fell. When people keep consuming nature faster than nature can regenerate, natural society (= the ecosystem) can no longer support human society.

Again and again in history, food production fell, it could no longer support the population, and civilization declined and collapsed. Why can human society not keep the peace, and why does it repeat war? In short, the answer is that the people who made up those societies had a low level of understanding of nature1.

A Civilization Forced to Depend on Chemical Fertilizer Will Surely Decline

In China, the floods of the Yellow River and the Yangtze brought fresh, fertile mud every year. In East Asia, including ancient Japan, people established circular agriculture that thoroughly returned human waste and compost to the soil. Thanks to this, these regions sustained stable agriculture and civilization for thousands of years.

As the saying “Egypt is the gift of the Nile” goes, the floods of the Nile kept the soil of ancient Egypt from becoming poor, and its civilization lasted for thousands of years. But when the Aswan High Dam was built in the 20th century and the floods stopped, Egypt was forced to depend on chemical fertilizer, as it does today.

In the New World of America, settlers from Europe cleared vast lands one after another, and when the soil became poor they moved west. As a result, huge dust storms (the Dust Bowl) struck in the 1930s and caused a severe agricultural crisis.

Looking down on the history of world civilizations, we can see a pattern: “A civilization that does not value soil declines and eventually falls.” Applying this pattern to the present, we can say that “a civilization forced to depend on chemical fertilizer will surely decline.”

Japan, Jomon and Terra Preta

Japan, which once built a circular society and sustained thousands of years of civilization with regenerative agriculture, is no exception. Before the Yayoi period, when it changed into an agricultural society, came the Jomon period. The Jomon is extremely unusual and rare in the world as “an example of a society that settled down without depending on agriculture and stayed peaceful and sustainable for more than 10,000 years.”

As shown below, the Jomon civilization of Japan succeeded in living together and in harmony with nature. It was a truly peaceful civilization.

  • The common route in the world: settling down ➔ population growth ➔ large-scale deforestation and agriculture ➔ soil loss, gaps between rich and poor, war ➔ collapse of civilization (hundreds to thousands of years)

  • The route of the Jomon period: settling down ➔ gathering, hunting and fishing in coexistence with the forest (+ small-scale cultivation) ➔ keeping the ecosystem without stripping the soil ➔ continuing for more than 10,000 years (almost no traces of large-scale war)

The soil of tropical rainforests is naturally very poor. Yet in the Amazon basin, ancient Indigenous peoples mixed charcoal, bones and organic waste into the soil, creating an extremely fertile, carbon-rich soil called “terra preta” (black earth), which supported large populations.

Earning Worldwide with “Smart” Farming ≠ Agricultural Revolution

Farming that does not value soil may make a civilization decline, but it never revives one. Where farming that does not value soil finally leads is collective apoptosis, a world-scale great war. The two world wars humanity experienced were caused by the shift to “farming that does not value soil” over the centuries before them.

Why can we say this? Because physically, it can be proven right away by calculating the energy balance of food production. Making conventional farming “smart,” which depends on chemicals and on large machines that burn a lot of fossil fuel to build and to run; growing luxury strawberries automatically in a plant factory; exporting delicious Aomori apples to East Asia: none of these is an agricultural revolution. They may be an “agricultural revolution” that earns 100 trillion yen in the human economy, but in the cosmic economy they are a fatal consumption of energy. They are nothing more than one of the entropy-conforming behaviors2 brought on by low intelligence, which will surely shorten the life of the civilization of humans, a living species on Earth.

Valuing Soil = Agricultural Revolution

We can call it an agricultural revolution only when humanity turns the physical energy balance of food production from negative to positive on a global scale. This can only be achieved by moving to a kind of farming in which the more we farm, the more fertile black soil builds up for our future descendants. Some Earthlings who love the Earth are aiming for a fundamental shift to this form of farming under the name “regenerative organic.”

Value the soil to the end. Regenerate only with radiant energy from the sun. Strengthen Earth’s biosphere with high intelligence. Live together with more and more life. Moving to such a civilization would be a revival of the Jomon civilization that Earthlings once experienced in ancient Japan. Spreading it universally across the world with modern science and technology is the greatest work of this century, which humanity must carry out together3. At Polymath Research, we call this “supernature.”

Footnotes

  1. If you want to learn more about the relationship between soil and civilization, we recommend Dirt: The Erosion of Civilizations by geologist David R. Montgomery. This essay is also based on that book and writes about what we personally felt and thought. ↩

  2. By “entropy-conforming,” we mean having a strong affinity with the law of increasing entropy. It does not mean actively increasing entropy, but acting in a way that matches entropy as it naturally increases. Intelligence does the opposite: through self-organization, it decreases entropy locally. ↩

  3. “Valuing life and soil” is the only way to achieve true world peace. Just as a cat raised among vertical stripes cannot recognize horizontal stripes, if you grow up in an unnatural environment, your senses become tuned to unnatural things. In developed regions, people may have become rich in material terms, but many are very poor in spirit. If school education keeps increasing the number of people who cannot recognize abnormal things as abnormal, humanity’s future is in danger. That is why both agriculture and education need to be reinvented. ↩

Older post

Polymath = Hyakusho

2026.10.19

Related Posts